Short answer: Granola7.7 out of 10 (7.7/10) is the best AI notetaker for most people, especially if you hate a bot joining your calls. Otter.ai6.9 out of 10 (6.9/10) is the simple, cheap choice for teams that live in Zoom, Meet or Teams and want an auto-joining transcriber. Fireflies.ai6.8 out of 10 (6.8/10) is the pick for sales teams that need CRM sync and conversation analytics.
This comparison is for anyone buying a meeting notetaker, whether you are a founder with back-to-back calls, a sales manager coaching reps or a remote team that wants a searchable archive. All three tools record, transcribe and summarize. They differ in how they capture audio, what they do with it afterwards and where the pricing gets awkward. Scores come from the weighted rubric on our methodology page, and no vendor influences them. All three sit in our Productivity category.
Quick picks:
- Best overall: Granola7.7 out of 10, 7.7. Free plan; Business from $14/user/month.
- Best for auto-joining meeting transcripts on a budget: Otter.ai6.9 out of 10, 6.9. Free plan; Pro from $8.33/month billed annually.
- Best for sales teams and multilingual calls: Fireflies.ai6.8 out of 10, 6.8. Free plan; Pro from $18/month, or $10/month billed annually.
Side by side
| Granola | Otter.ai | Fireflies.ai | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Overall | 7.7 | 6.9 | 6.8 |
| Capability | 7 | 7 | 8 |
| Ease of use | 9 | 8 | 6 |
| Value | 8 | 7 | 6 |
| Reliability | 8 | 6 | 7 |
| Support & docs | 6 | 6 | 6 |
| Capture method | System audio on your device, no bot | Bot (OtterPilot) joins the call | Bot (“Fred”) joins the call |
| Paid plan from | $14/user/month | $8.33/month, annual | $18/month ($10 annual) |
| Standout feature | Your shorthand merged with the transcript | Slide screenshots, real-time transcript | CRM push, conversation analytics, Live Assist |
| Biggest risk | Narrow scope, cloud processing | Class-action lawsuit, minute caps | Upgrade cliff to Business |
Granola wins on ease of use and reliability. Fireflies wins on raw capability. Otter lands in the middle on most scores, and its reliability score of 6 is the lowest of the three. Support and docs score 6 for all three, so none of them is a clear winner on service.
Granola: the notes you would have written
Granola runs as a desktop app that captures system audio directly, so nobody sees a “recording assistant has joined” banner. You jot rough shorthand during the call, and Granola merges those notes with the full transcript into a structured writeup that follows your emphasis instead of a generic template. That is the main reason it scores 9 on ease of use.
Beyond single meetings, you can chat across your whole archive, share folders with a team and pull meeting context into other tools through an MCP server and API. Business integrations include Notion, HubSpot, Attio, Affinity and Zapier. The Business plan is $14/user/month for unlimited history, which we confirmed on Granola’s pricing page; Enterprise is $35/user/month.
Weaknesses:
- It captures, it does not act. Granola does not yet follow up, update your CRM unprompted or run multi-step tasks. If you want that, look at the proactive agents we cover in our Claude Duet launch report.
- “No bot” does not mean on-device. Audio is processed in the cloud by third-party subprocessors, and org-wide opt-out of model training is gated to Enterprise.
- Mobile is young. Android only shipped in July 2026.
- The free plan limits history, so archive-wide chat is only really useful on a paid seat.
Otter.ai: the easy auto-joiner
Otter’s OtterPilot joins calendar-scheduled meetings on Zoom, Google Meet and Microsoft Teams, transcribes in real time with speaker labels, captures slide screenshots and sends a summary with action items. Otter AI Chat searches your archive, and a 2026 MCP server lets tools such as Claude and ChatGPT read your meeting history. It is also the cheapest paid plan of the three at $8.33/month billed annually, and the Business plan is $19.99/user/month billed annually, both of which match Otter’s pricing page.
Weaknesses:
- Legal risk. Otter is the subject of a consolidated US federal class action over recording participants who did not consent, unresolved as of mid-2026. If you record external parties, think carefully about consent.
- Accuracy drops with accents, cross-talk and noise, so transcripts often need cleanup.
- Narrow language support, mainly English, French and Spanish.
- Minute caps. Free gives 300 minutes a month with a 30-minute limit per conversation. Pro gives 1,200 minutes and 90 minutes per conversation, which heavy meeting schedules exhaust.
- Pricing is confusing. Monthly billing costs more than the annual rate quoted above, and Otter’s page shows promotional Pro prices tied to specific regions, so check what you will actually pay.
Fireflies.ai: the sales team’s workhorse
Fireflies’ bot joins Zoom, Meet, Teams, Webex and more than 50 other tools and delivers a transcript, summary and action items. It supports 100+ languages, reports about 95% accuracy on clean audio and has the widest integration list, with 200+ connections. AskFred answers questions across your meeting history, and Live Assist offers real-time suggestions during a call. On Business and above, summaries and action items push into Salesforce or HubSpot automatically, and conversation analytics track talk time, sentiment and topics.
Weaknesses:
- The upgrade cliff. CRM sync, video recording, analytics and API access sit behind Business at $29/month, 61% more than Pro. For ten people that is about $1,320 extra a year at monthly rates.
- The bot is visible, and recording-consent liability sits with you in all-party-consent jurisdictions.
- Ease of use scores 6. Speaker identification needs manual setup and slips in multi-accent meetings.
- The free plan is a trial. It caps storage at 800 minutes and gives a one-time pool of AI credits.
- EU note: sentiment analysis may conflict with EU AI Act provisions, so check with legal first.
Fireflies’ pricing page did not publish figures when we checked, so the prices above come from our agent profile reviewed in October 2026. Confirm them with the vendor before you buy.
What each one really costs
| Free | Entry paid | Team / CRM tier | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Granola | Limited history | $14/user/month | Enterprise $35 |
| Otter.ai | 300 min/month | $8.33/month annual | Business $19.99/user/month annual |
| Fireflies.ai | 800 min storage | $18/month ($10 annual) | Business $29/month ($19 annual) |
Per seat, Otter is cheapest and Granola’s Business plan is the best value for a feature set that includes unlimited history and integrations. Fireflies becomes expensive once you need CRM sync. For wider context on why headline prices rarely tell the whole story, see our AI agent pricing guide, and for a smaller-team view, our best AI tools for small business ranking.
Which should you choose?
- If you want notes that read like yours and no bot on the call, choose Granola.
- If you meet clients who might object to a recorder, choose Granola, but still ask permission.
- If you want the cheapest paid plan and mostly run Zoom, Meet or Teams, choose Otter.ai.
- If you need a clean, verbatim-style transcript with slide screenshots, choose Otter.ai.
- If you run a sales team and want CRM updates and call coaching, choose Fireflies.ai on Business.
- If your calls are in many languages, start with Fireflies.ai.
- If you want an assistant that acts on what was said, none of these does that yet. Meeting capture is the layer underneath.
Whatever you pick, run a two-week trial on your real meetings. Noisy rooms, accents and cross-talk expose differences that vendor demos hide.
Next step
Open the profiles to compare sub-scores, plans and security notes: Granola7.7 out of 10, Otter.ai6.9 out of 10 and Fireflies.ai6.8 out of 10. If sales calls are your main use, also browse the Sales category.
Frequently asked questions
Is Granola better than Otter?
On our scores, yes: Granola 7.7 against Otter 6.9. Granola is easier to use, more reliable and has no meeting bot. Otter is cheaper at the entry paid tier and adds slide screenshots, but it has narrower language support and a pending consent class action.
Does Granola join meetings as a bot?
No. It captures system audio from your desktop, so participants see nothing unusual. Audio is still processed in the cloud, so it is not an on-device product.
Is Fireflies worth it over Otter?
Choose Fireflies if you need CRM sync, conversation analytics or 100+ languages. Those features need Business at $29/month. If you only need transcripts and summaries, Otter is cheaper and simpler.
Are AI notetakers legal to use?
It depends on where participants are. In all-party-consent jurisdictions you generally need everyone’s permission to record. Tell attendees at the start of the call and check with legal for regulated or external meetings.
Which has the best free plan?
Otter’s free plan gives 300 minutes a month. Granola’s free plan limits meeting history, and Fireflies’ free plan caps storage at 800 minutes with one-time AI credits. None is enough for heavy daily use.